The Candidate as Rock Star

Crossposted at Future Majority

Yesterday, Barack Obama came to Philadelphia for a series of fundraisers, including one at the city's biggest venue, the Electric Factory. The event was was seen by the event's promoters as proof that Obama is "a new kind of candidate," since the electric factory (Clear Channel's 2500-person venue) is certainly not the place that candidates typically hold rallies at, and since $25 for students or $50 for general admission is not the typical cost for 20 minutes in front of a Presidential hopeful (though it is more than a typical concert ticket).  I'm not an Obama supporter (yet) so I wasn't planning on throwing down $50 to see the Senetor from Illinois.  Obama also pissed off me and just about every other young activist in the city a few weeks back (as well as many of the city's donors, from small to large) when he butted his nose into the mayoral election by backing Congressman (and member of the Commission of Fellas With Unusual Names) Chaka Fattah, who ended up coming in fourth in a five person race, over reform candidate Michael Nutter (who will be our next Mayor).  I also am a little disturbed by the whole rock start persona that Obama seems to be cultivating, which feeds into my fears that his campaign is all image and hope over substance.

But, I received a few free tickets the night before the event, so I decided to check it out. Once I picked up the tickets I found out that the event was going to be held at 5pm, but that doors would open promptly at 4, an odd time to hold an event since most people don't get off work until after 5. I figured it was just like any other concert, and that 4pm doors meant that the event would really start at 6, and so I decided to wait for some of my friends to get off work (who I had tickets for) to go. When I got to the event at 4:50 the doors were already closed, and the Secret Service wasn't letting anyone else in. So, I was left to mill around in the parking lot outside, and while it wasn't anywhere near as fun as the Grateful Dead parking lots I used to stumble through as a teenager, it was certainly entertaining. First of all, it's always fun to watch State Representatives, Judges, and various other local "important people" argue with bouncers over admittance to a club, espescially when they paid between $50-100 for the chance to come within smelling distance of the future Vice President Presidential hopeful. Hell, I even got to talk for a minute with the new Democratic nominee to traffic court with the $11,000 in outstanding traffic tickets, the suspended license, and the warrant out for his arrest ("it's all a big, misunderstanding!)-- ah, only in Philadelphia. At some point my friend State Rep Tony Payton arrived, and when I went over to tell him not to bother paying for parking because the doors were closed (I didn't realize at the time that Tony was supposed to deliver the opening speech, but that he was stuck in Harrisburg) some female Obama staffer, who was in the passenger seat, opened his passenger side window and started screaming at me (note to the Obama campaign: you better learn the terrain of the places you go before hand. You don't want to get your staffers injured- this is Philly, not Kansas, scream at us an we'll make you eat your blackberry). I look forward to meeting this young woman again, I certainly won't forget her face or attitude.

Anyway, after about 30 minutes of hanging out in the lot, the doors opened and the hundreds of people who had made it into the venue on time started to stream out. That's when I realized that I would volunteer for Obama, but only if I get divorced in the next few months, because the place was filled with very beautiful women. Actually, I think that the large number of good looking gals bodes well for Obama's chances of raising a youth army to get new people excited about his race (if they don't have pictures of all the hotties up on flickr in the next few days than the terrorists have already won). And while I think I am now less likely to vote for or support Obama in any way, I do think that it's great that a candidate is exciting the youngens about politics, and I hope that he can sustain that excitement through the election. On the other hand, if the Obama campaign is as clumsy and rude towards the slightly older activists in every city it visits (i.e. people like me who are a lot more involved, who do a lot more work, who have a lot more friends who vote/donate, and who are serving as bridges between the netroots and the older politicos) than their campaign is going nowhere fast. I wonder if Obama's drop in recent polls is a result of people finally coming in touch with his campaign. I know that inexperience can give a candidate a certain air of an outsider, but it can also lead their campaign to do really stupid things that alienate people who they absolutely must win over.



Display:


Re: The Candidate as Rock Star (3.00 / 1)

See, I was at the event too, and I thought it was pretty well-run.  All the notices made clear that people really did need to show up at 4pm, and the timing of the event was based on other events meetings Obama was having yesterday, including a half-hour sitdown with Michael Nutter.


by Adam B on Wed May 23, 2007 at 12:41:03 PM EST

Re: The Candidate as Rock Star (none / 0)

I hadn't paid any attention to the event before I got the tickets, and while I was told that doors were opening at 4 I've been told the same thing a million times in the past, only to find myself standing around for hours waiting. Either way, I didn't really mind getting locked out, from what I can gather I didn't miss too much.

I wonder how the meeting with Michael went-- the fact that Obama's large donor funders in the city are the same that gave heavily to Nutter probably necessitated a big "I'm sorry" from Obama. Or maybe not- does being a rock star mean never having to say "I'm sorry?" I for one think a green politician from  Illinois should keep his hands out of a local political race in a city he doesn't know or understand, and I know quite a few people who feel the same way.


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 01:29:03 PM EST
[ Parent ]

bill clinton did fundraiser for chaka fattah (none / 0)


are you complaining about that too?

looks like your ego was bruised by the campaign staffer. and your concerns have been noted.

but quite frankly there's an element of cruetly in your attitude. first of all the rock star labelled was put on white politicians like bill clinton, JFK and other candidates who seemed to connect with voters.

that has nothing to do with barack himself. he fought his way up the ladder as a politician in illinois(rahm emmanuel and co. wrote him off even before he started) and today he might be a 'rock star' but as he writes in his books, a black politician like himself was written off even before he had a chance to prove what he was made up of.

so this strong tinge of dislike of him because of labels he's been posted with strike me as immature. and you must re-examine your motives.


by pmb on Wed May 23, 2007 at 01:57:33 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: bill clinton did fundraiser for chaka fattah (none / 0)

Bill Clinton did a fundraiser for his congressional campaign which is a totally different than interfering in an extremely important local election. It was also fantastically stupid on Obama's part, because Fattah came in 4th, and Nutter had almost all of the support of the city's small donors and activists. It was a dumb move, plain and simple, because it didn't help Fattah and actually hurt Obama.

My ego was not bruised by anyone at the event, though I was pissed off by the staffer. That doesn't mean that I won't help Obama's campaign in the future, it does make it less likely. It also does mean that any staffers who go into unknown terrain should be a lot more careful- there's a lot more at stake at times than bruised egos.

I must reexamine my motives? What motives are those?


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 02:09:59 PM EST
[ Parent ]

huh? congressional elections and mayoral elections (none / 0)


are that polar different?

and by the way it must be clear to you that people don't vote for endorsements. barack himself got no endorsements of importance in his primary in illinois.


by pmb on Wed May 23, 2007 at 02:20:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]

they are different (none / 0)

I don't know if they are that "polar" different, but they certainly are very different.

And you are right as far as voting goes, but as for volunteers and donors, I don't think you are correct. If you are volunteering night and day for a candidate, or giving them all of the money you can afford to, and some out-of-state candidate comes in and takes the opposing side, are you likely to support said candidate in the future? Which is why I said it was a really stupid move- it didn't help Fattah and actually hurt Obama.


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 02:40:11 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: bill clinton did fundraiser for chaka fattah (none / 0)

He came in with a late fundraising email for the one guy in the race he knew.  Not exactly beating the hustings for Fattah.


by Adam B on Wed May 23, 2007 at 11:34:38 PM EST
[ Parent ]

and actually... (none / 0)

You are pointing to two candidates who are great examples of what I am weary of. I personally feel that both Clinton and JFK were image over substance, and I am definitely afraid of another DLC President who provides "hope" (remember Clinton's video at the DNC event before his first election?) instead of results.


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 02:12:21 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Adam... (none / 0)

Are you planning on writing anything about the event? I'm actually pretty curious to hear the thoughts of Obama supporters who were there...


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 01:49:03 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Adam... (none / 0)

I am so non-objective, though.  Maybe.


by Adam B on Wed May 23, 2007 at 10:11:07 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: The Candidate as Rock Star (none / 0)

That was my experience in Milwaukee. All those who purchased their tickets on line and were advised that while the doors opened up at 6pm, they would need to be there at 5pm to pick up tickets. I went there at five. There were TONS of people and a huge line. The lobby where I and other Internet ticket purchasers were waiting to pick up our tickets was jam packed. Everyone was excited and talking about Barack Obama. I met some really cool people. Then , at six, we all filed into the Theater where I got a really good seat. Two precious little black children came out onto the stage. The little five or six year old boy played the violin while his older sister sang Gob Bless America. Then we met the family. Then the Major came out and spoke to us. Then Barack Obama came out and addressed us.

My only complaint:

People in Milwaukee are very aggressive drivers and the roads down town are too narrow. I guess it's all Barack Obamas fault.

NOT!


"I don't believe in this can't do, won't do, won't even try style of politics. Yes We Can!" ~ Barack Obama
by ObamaEdwards2008 on Wed May 23, 2007 at 06:44:15 PM EST
[ Parent ]

where's the eh (none / 0)


substance of this report. so what actually happened at the rally?
by pmb on Wed May 23, 2007 at 01:21:41 PM EST

here's the eh (none / 0)

what actually happened is  I got there 5 minutes after doors closed and waited outside for a half hour, along with a couple of hundred of other people (mostly people with jobs), for the event to end.


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 01:33:12 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: The Candidate as Rock Star (3.00 / 1)

don't take this personally but what exactly is your problem? You are less likely to support a candidate because of campaign rally logistics? The events Obama is having are big and he needs to be protected by the secret service for obvious reasons so thiers going to be some crowd control issues, this type of complaining is stupid , if you have disagreements over issues that's one thing but this stuff bothers me.


Obama! because 51% isn't enough!
by nevadadem on Wed May 23, 2007 at 01:34:13 PM EST

no... (none / 0)

I am less likely to support a candidate who stuck his nose into a local political race that he had no business sticking his nose into. The fact that his campaign staffer yelled at me, which had nothing to do with campaign logistics, again indicated to me a staff that doesn't understand the space they are operating in. Talking down to/yelling at people in Philly is dangerous. Period.

I completely understood why they had to shut the doors, and was not upset by it in the least. I don't believe my post was a "complaint" about the event, though I did suspect that the "true believers" would see it as such.


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 01:41:48 PM EST
[ Parent ]

A report from inside... (none / 0)

This is what the popular local blog Philebrity had to say, for those looking at a view from the inside:
If Barack Obama is the "rock star" candidate, then I'm Paris Hilton.
Which is to say, maybe I'm jaded from too many nights seeing real rock shows at the Electric Factory, but reports of Obama's electricity are greatly exaggerated.
Read the rest after the jump!
News reports told us about Obama the "political rock star" but offered no real evidence to support that neat little turn of phrase. Yes, he played the Factory, but there was far more anticipation in the air when Amy Winehouse took the stage the other week. This wasn't exactly Springsteen at the Meadowlands -- hell, it wasn't even Springsteen at the Vet.
Here's what I saw and heard:
The crowd downstairs, where tickets went for $25 and $50, was overwhelmingly white, but a nice demographic mix. Upstairs, in the $100-a-pop "VIP" area, you had a feeling every significant African-American businessperson, power broker and scenester in Philly was on hand. And people weren't just there to make a fuss over the first viable black presidential candidate -- the entire crowd was far quieter than I'd expected but it seemed to be because they were really listening to what Obama had to say.
Also, contrary to what the Inky said, the biggest applause line I heard was not -- surprise -- when he called for an end to the war but when he talked about ending the genocide in Darfur.
And buddy, that ain't gonna get you to the White House.


Future Majority / Young Philly Politics
by Alex Urevick on Wed May 23, 2007 at 02:49:05 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.